CBSETest.comby Bimal Publications

Need help with The Crisis of Democratic Order?

Practice Tests
Class 12 · Political Science NCERT Class 12 Political Science · Ch. 137 min read · 15 questions

The Crisis of Democratic Order

Political Science

The Crisis of Democratic Order

Introduction

The period from 1973 to 1977 represents the most serious challenge to Indian democracy since Independence. A combination of economic crisis, political opposition, judicial rulings, and ultimately the declaration of Emergency by Prime Minister Indira Gandhi in June 1975 tested whether India's democratic institutions could survive authoritarian pressures. The story of this crisis — and democracy's restoration — is a crucial chapter in Indian political history.

Background: The Crisis Builds (1973-74)

After the euphoria of 1971-72 (Bangladesh victory and state election wins), India faced severe problems:

  • Economic crisis: The 1973 global oil shock quadrupled oil prices. India's import bill soared, inflation hit ordinary people hard, and industrial production stagnated.
  • Bihar Movement (1974): Jayaprakash Narayan (JP), a veteran freedom fighter and socialist, emerged as the leader of a mass student movement in Bihar demanding dissolution of the state government over corruption and misgovernance. JP called for "Total Revolution" (Sampoorna Kranti) — a fundamental change in the political, economic, and social order.
  • Railway Strike (1974): Railway workers under George Fernandes called a massive national railway strike. The government cracked down harshly, arresting thousands.

The Allahabad High Court Judgment (June 1975)

The critical trigger was a court verdict. Indira Gandhi's 1971 election from Rae Bareli was challenged by her opponent, Raj Narain. The Allahabad High Court in June 1975 found her guilty of electoral malpractice — using government machinery for her campaign (specifically, a government official organising election work and use of the Air Force plane). The court set aside her election and disqualified her from holding elected office for 6 years.

  1. 1.This meant she would have to resign as Prime Minister. Instead, she:
  2. 2.Appealed to the Supreme Court (which granted a conditional stay — she could remain PM but could not vote in Parliament).
  3. 3.Meanwhile, opposition demanded her resignation.

Declaration of Emergency (June 25-26, 1975)

On the night of June 25-26, 1975, President Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed proclaimed a state of National Emergency under Article 352 of the Constitution, citing "internal disturbance" (the JP movement and opposition agitation were framed as a threat to national security).

  • What happened during the Emergency (1975-77)?
  • Fundamental Rights (especially the right to personal liberty under Article 21) were suspended.
  • Preventive detention laws (MISA — Maintenance of Internal Security Act) were used to arrest thousands without trial. Prominent opposition leaders arrested included JP Narayan, Morarji Desai, Atal Bihari Vajpayee, L.K. Advani.
  • Press censorship: Newspapers were required to submit content for pre-publication government approval. Some newspapers blacked out editorials in protest.
  • Parliament was sidelined: Constitutional amendments were passed rapidly (including the 42nd Amendment, called the "mini-Constitution") without meaningful debate.
  • Forced sterilisation: Sanjay Gandhi (Indira's son) pushed an aggressive family planning programme; reports of forced sterilisations came from across the country, especially targeting the poor.
  • Demolitions: Slums in Delhi (Turkman Gate demolitions) were cleared displacing thousands.

The 42nd Constitutional Amendment (1976)

  • Called the "mini-Constitution" due to its sweeping changes:
  • Added "Socialist" and "Secular" to the Preamble.
  • Extended the Lok Sabha and state assemblies' terms from 5 to 6 years.
  • Made Directive Principles superior to Fundamental Rights.
  • Curtailed judicial review powers.

Resistance and Restoration

Not everyone complied with Emergency. George Fernandes went underground and organised resistance. The RSS and various opposition groups continued quiet resistance. Many journalists found ways to publish criticism. Abroad, the Indian diaspora protested.

In January 1977, Indira Gandhi surprised everyone by calling elections, perhaps believing she would win. The opposition united to form the Janata Party — a coalition including Jan Sangh, Congress (O), socialists, and others. Indira released political prisoners and lifted Emergency.

1977 Elections: The Janata Party won a massive majority; Congress suffered its worst ever defeat. Morarji Desai became India's first non-Congress Prime Minister. This was a remarkable vindication of Indian democracy — voters peacefully removed an authoritarian government through the ballot box.

Why Did Emergency End Democracy's Threat?

  • The Janata government (1977-79) passed the 44th Amendment (1978) which:
  • Restored "right to life" as non-suspendable even during Emergency
  • Changed "internal disturbance" to "armed rebellion" as justification for Emergency
  • Required Cabinet's written recommendation for Emergency proclamation

Common mistakes

  • The Emergency was declared under Article 352, not Article 356 (which is President's Rule in states).
  • Sanjay Gandhi was not an elected official but wielded enormous power as Indira's son.
  • The 42nd Amendment was passed during the Emergency; the 44th Amendment was passed after (by Janata government to reverse Emergency changes).
  • Allahabad HC found Indira guilty of election malpractices, not corruption in office.

Summary

The Emergency (1975-77) was India's greatest democratic crisis. Triggered by the Allahabad HC judgment and JP's movement, Indira Gandhi used Article 352 to suspend fundamental rights and jail opponents. Press censorship, forced sterilisations, and demolitions marked this period. Crucially, when Indira called elections in 1977, Indians voted her out, demonstrating that 30 years of democratic practice had created a public committed to democratic norms. The Janata government then strengthened constitutional safeguards through the 44th Amendment.

Practice Problems

15 questions with instant feedback.

Question 1 of 15Score 0

Under which Article of the Indian Constitution was the National Emergency declared in June 1975?